Is social security subject to federal tax

Up to 50% or even 85% of your Social security benefits are taxable if your “provisional” or total income, as defined by tax law, is above a certain base amount. Your Social Security income may not be taxable at all if your total income is below the base amount.

If you’re married and filing jointly with your spouse, your combined incomes and social security benefits are used to figure your total income.

When Is Social Security Income Taxable?

To determine when Social Security income is taxable, you’ll first need to calculate your total income. Generally, the formula for total income for this purpose is: your adjusted gross income, including any nontaxable interest, plus half of your Social Security benefits.

If you’re married and filing jointly with your spouse, your combined incomes and social security benefits are used to figure your total income.

Then you’ll compare your total income with the base amounts for your filing status to find out how much of your Social Security income is taxable, if any.

You’ll see that you fall into one of three categories. If your total income is:

• Below the base amount, your Social Security benefits are not taxable.
• Between the base and maximum amount, your Social Security income is taxable up to 50%.
• Above the maximum amount, your Social Security benefits are taxable up to 85%.

How Much of Your Social Security Income is Taxable?

Review the list below to determine where your total income falls and how much of your Social Security income is taxable. For:

• Single, Head of Household or Qualifying Widow(er), the base amount is $25,000 and the maximum is $34,000.
• Married filing jointly, the base amount is $32,000 and the maximum is $44,000.
• Married filing separately, the base amount is $0 and the maximum is $0. (Note: married filing separate filers who lived apart the entire tax year use the same base and maximum amounts as single filers.)

Are All Kinds of Social Security Income Taxable?

All social security benefits are taxable in the same way. This is true whether they’re retirement, survivors, or disability benefits. Take note that Social Security benefits paid to a child under his or her Social Security number (SSN) could be potentially taxable to the child, not the parent. Note: Supplemental Security Income, or SSI, is a non-taxable needs-based federal benefit. It is not part of Social Security benefits and does not figure into the taxable benefit formula.

Related Topics

Real estate Wages Investments Retirement income

Related Resources

Garage Sale Money and Capital Gains: What You Should Report to the IRS

Do capital gains apply to garage sale money? The answer depends on a number of factors. Learn more at H&R Block.

For Pro Golfers, Tough Taxes Are Par for the Course

Professional golfer taxes can be complicated and confusing. Learn more about tricky golfer tax issues like travel deductions and residency rules with H&R Block.

How Renting Out Your Extra Bedrooms Affects Your Taxes

Thinking about renting out a room in your home? Learn more about the potential tax implications with the experts at H&R Block.

How do I calculate taxable income?

Finding your taxable income is an important part of filing taxes. Learn how to calculate your taxable income with help from the experts at H&R Block.

On Thursday, the Social Security Administration (SSA) announced the cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for Social Security payments based on inflation over the previous year. This has brought renewed attention to how the tax code treats Social Security benefits, which can be a confusing subject for taxpayers.

Each year, SSA adjusts Social Security benefits for inflation, much like how certain aspects of the tax code are indexed for inflation. In 2022, for example, Social Security recipients received a 5.9 percent adjustment. For 2023, the cost-of-living adjustment is expected to rise to about 8.7 percent, driven by unusually high inflation that reduces the nominal value of existing Social Security benefits. 

The tax treatment of Social Security benefits is complicated and can trip up taxpayers and tax experts alike. That’s because the tax code treats Social Security benefits differently from other types of income. First, taxpayers calculate their “combined income,” defined as their adjusted gross income (AGI), tax-exempt interest income, and half of their Social Security benefits.

Taxpayers who earn less than $25,000 (single filers) or $32,000 (joint filers) in combined income pay no tax on their benefits. Households earning between those thresholds and up to $34,000 (single filers) or $44,000 (joint filers) pay tax on up to 50 percent of their benefits. Above those levels, up to 85 percent of benefits are taxed.

The combined income thresholds were originally established in 1984 and updated in 1993, but have not been indexed for inflation. This means that a larger portion of Social Security benefits will be taxed over time due to bracket creep, especially true in a time of high inflation.

Some policymakers have proposed exempting Social Security payments from income tax altogether, arguing that this could help provide relief from high inflation. While there is a strong case for indexing the combined income thresholds for inflation much like we have indexed ordinary income tax brackets, it would be a step too far to entirely exempt Social Security income from tax. However, there are ways to improve the tax treatment of benefits.

Under the current tax code, employees cannot deduct their portion of payroll taxes paid from their income tax liability, but employers can deduct their portion of the payroll tax as an ordinary business expense (with exceptions for non-profits or firms incurring losses). One way to think about this is that half of the contribution from the payroll tax is treated like a traditional retirement account, where there is a deduction for saving up front, and half is treated like a Roth account, where tax is paid up front.

This means that a portion of the Social Security benefits should be taxed when received, though there are disagreements about the precise amount that should be subject to tax. The tax treatment of Social Security benefits is also complicated by the fact that beneficiary contributions are not tightly linked to benefits as they are with defined contribution plans such as traditional or Roth 401K accounts.

No matter how we think about them conceptually, Social Security benefits should still be considered income, and it would be proper to include them in the income tax base. Broad exemptions from the income tax would not provide longer-term relief from inflation for beneficiaries and would continue the long-running trend of narrowing the income tax base at the cost of higher tax rates.

However, there are options to simplify and improve the tax treatment of benefits. These include indexing the combined income thresholds for inflation and moving away from a confusing mix of traditional and Roth-style treatment.

Instead, the tax code could treat benefits as a traditional or Roth form of saving by either fully taxing or exempting benefits as they are received and modifying how payroll tax deductions are treated in kind. While this may not solve every challenge associated with taxing defined benefits, it would be a simpler process for taxpayers.